
The walls of sound that Brand New had built and drenched with noise during their last outing have been forgone in Daisy, replaced instead with small hurdles. The last records stray sounds, echo laden acoustics, and swells of guitars and voices have left, and in their stead are the constant screaming, double-bass drumming, exacting formulaic riffs that make up the new album. It's not that it's bad, it's just that it feels off.
What made The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me tick was such a balancing act of so many factors that every listen reveals some small detail that I didn't catch the last time. Like Stanley Kubrick's The Shining, so much went on that it's impossible to keep track of what is there to surprise the audience and what is there just by incident. Trying to recreate all that over again with Daisy proved impossible in spirit and in practice. They just couldn't topple the monster that they had had created.
The first point against it is that Daisy comes off as too aggressive too fast. Vices, the first track, hits you so hard with so much that after it's three-and-a-half minutes are up, you are left with no payoff. "You Stole" is so mired in it's own melancholy that I couldn't really be bothered by the time the song opens up and gets good.
Point two: The album's lyrics are weak and non-cohesive. Vague references to trains abound and some verses are just silly such as the bridge of "Sink" where "bony" is rhymed with "phony," which could work when pulled off properly, but it just sounds childish.
It's musically very tight and well done, and there are some exciting ideas and concepts within, but as a whole, it just doesn't, and can't, live up to the tightrope walk of their last release.
That's not to say that every band should live up to my exacting expectations, but Brand New has exceeded them with every new album, which leaves me in a rough spot.
The more I listen to it, the more I hate it, the more I want to point out what would be better, what they could of changed, but it's futile because this band means a lot to me, and I love this album anyway. I think I just had too much invested in it that I was bound to be let down.

